Five Guys Milkshake Menu: Flavors, Sizes & More
Craving a creamy dessert after a salty burger? This famous brand selection offers a perfect way to end your meal on a sweet note. You can enjoy hand-spun delights featuring a rich vanilla base and your choice of many mix-ins.
What makes these beverages special is the sheer variety of milkshake flavors available for every customer. From savory bacon bits to classic strawberry, the options allow for endless creativity at this popular American chain.
Finding the right combination is half the fun when you visit. This guide explores everything you need to know about the sizes and ingredients that make these drinks famous across the United States.
Key Takeaways
- Unlimited mix-in combinations are available for one flat price.
- Every order starts with a premium, high-quality vanilla base.
- Customers can choose unique additions like crispy, salty bacon bits.
- Fresh fruit options include real strawberries and mashed bananas.
- Optional real whipped cream provides a rich and light finish.
- The brand maintains a consistent single-size portion for all locations.
What Makes Five Guys Hand-Spun Milkshakes Stand Out
The allure of Five Guys milkshakes lies in their rich flavors and hand-spun preparation. Unlike many fast-food chains that rely on automated machines, Five Guys takes pride in the personal touch they bring to every milkshake.
Hand-Spun Preparation: The process of hand-spinning milkshakes ensures a thickness and creaminess that is hard to achieve with automated systems. This method allows for a more controlled blending process, resulting in a consistent texture that customers love.
High-Quality Ingredients: Five Guys uses high-quality ice cream and mix-ins to create their milkshakes. The base ice cream is rich and creamy, providing a perfect foundation for a variety of flavors.
| Feature | Description | Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| Hand-Spun | Milkshakes are blended to order | Ensures thickness and creaminess |
| High-Quality Ingredients | Rich ice cream and varied mix-ins | Provides a rich and varied flavor profile |
| Customization | Variety of flavors and mix-ins available | Allows customers to create their perfect milkshake |
Five Guys milkshakes are not just a treat; they’re an experience. The combination of hand-spun preparation and high-quality ingredients makes them stand out as some of the best milkshakes available in the fast-food industry.
Complete Five Guys Milkshake Menu Breakdown
Diving into the world of Five Guys milkshakes reveals a diverse menu that’s sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. The menu is divided into base milkshake flavors and additional flavor options, giving customers a wide range of choices.
Base Milkshake Flavors
Five Guys offers three base milkshake flavors that form the foundation of their milkshake menu. These classic flavors are a great starting point for any milkshake lover.
Chocolate Milkshake
The chocolate milkshake is a rich and creamy treat for those who love chocolate. Made with high-quality ingredients, it’s a decadent delight.
Vanilla Milkshake
The vanilla milkshake is a smooth and velvety option for those who prefer a more subtle flavor. It’s a versatile base that pairs well with various mix-ins.
Strawberry Milkshake
The strawberry milkshake offers a sweet and fruity twist on the classic milkshake. It’s a refreshing choice for warm weather or anytime you crave something fruity.
Additional Flavor Options
In addition to their base flavors, Five Guys offers a variety of additional flavor options to enhance your milkshake experience. These flavors can be mixed and matched to create unique combinations.
Bacon Milkshake
For a savory twist, the bacon milkshake combines the richness of bacon with the creaminess of a milkshake.
Peanut Butter Milkshake
The peanut butter milkshake is a creamy and nutty treat that’s perfect for peanut butter lovers.
Coffee Milkshake
The coffee milkshake is a great pick-me-up for coffee enthusiasts, blending the richness of coffee with the smoothness of a milkshake.
Malted Milk
Malted milk adds a unique flavor dimension to your milkshake, with a subtle malted taste.
Cherry
The cherry flavor adds a fruity and sweet element to your milkshake, perfect for those who enjoy a hint of cherry.
Salted Caramel
Salted caramel brings a deep, caramel flavor with a touch of salt, enhancing the overall taste of your milkshake.
Oreo Cookie
The Oreo cookie flavor incorporates the classic taste of Oreos into your milkshake, creating a cookies-and-cream experience.
Bananas
Bananas add a natural sweetness and creamy texture to your milkshake, making it a great option for those looking for a fruity twist.
| Base Flavor | Additional Flavor Options |
|---|---|
| Chocolate | Bacon, Peanut Butter, Coffee |
| Vanilla | Malted Milk, Cherry, Salted Caramel |
| Strawberry | Oreo Cookie, Bananas |
Understanding Milkshake Sizes and Portions at Five Guys
Choosing the perfect Five Guys milkshake involves more than just picking a flavor; it’s also about selecting the right size. Five Guys offers two milkshake sizes: regular and large. Understanding the differences between these sizes can help you make an informed decision that suits your appetite and preferences.
Regular Milkshake Size
The regular milkshake size at Five Guys is a generous serving that’s perfect for those looking for a treat without overindulging.
Volume and Serving Details
The regular size contains 12 oz of creamy milkshake goodness. It’s a substantial serving that can satisfy your sweet tooth without being overwhelming.
Best For
This size is ideal for:
- Those looking for a smaller indulgence
- Individuals with smaller appetites
- Anyone wanting to try multiple flavors
Large Milkshake Size
For those with a bigger appetite or a desire to share, Five Guys offers a large milkshake size that’s sure to impress.
Volume and Serving Details
The large size is 22 oz, making it more than enough for two people to enjoy or for one person with a hearty appetite.
Value Considerations
When deciding on the large size, consider:
- The value for money, as it’s often more cost-effective per ounce than the regular size
- Whether you’re planning to share with someone else
- If you have a larger appetite and want to indulge fully
Five Guys Milkshake Prices Across the United States
When it comes to indulging in a Five Guys milkshake, understanding the pricing is crucial for a satisfying experience. The cost of these delicious treats can vary based on location and customization options.
Standard Pricing Structure
Five Guys maintains a relatively consistent pricing structure across its locations. The base price of a milkshake is the starting point, with additional costs for mix-ins.
Base Milkshake Cost
The base cost of a Five Guys milkshake varies slightly depending on the size. Generally, the regular size is priced lower than the large size.
Mix-In Pricing
Mix-ins are a great way to customize your milkshake. Each mix-in comes at an additional cost, allowing you to create your perfect blend.
Here’s a breakdown of the typical costs associated with Five Guys milkshakes:
| Size | Base Price | Mix-In Price |
|---|---|---|
| Regular | $4.50 | $0.50 |
| Large | $5.50 | $0.50 |
Regional Price Differences
Prices can vary slightly from one region to another due to factors like taxes and operational costs. It’s not uncommon to find a few cents difference between locations.
Value for Money Analysis
Considering the quality and quantity of the milkshakes, Five Guys offers a competitive pricing strategy. The generous portions and variety of flavors make their milkshakes a great value for money.

Customers often praise Five Guys for their generous portions and the ability to customize their milkshakes with various mix-ins. This flexibility, combined with the quality of the product, makes Five Guys a popular choice for milkshake lovers.
In conclusion, while prices may vary slightly across different regions, the overall pricing structure of Five Guys milkshakes remains consistent and competitive. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic flavor or want to try something new with mix-ins, Five Guys offers a range of options to suit your taste and budget.
How to Customize Your Five Guys Milkshake
Take your Five Guys milkshake to the next level by customizing it with a variety of delicious mix-ins and toppings. Five Guys is known for its flexibility and willingness to let customers create their perfect treat.
All Available Mix-Ins and Toppings
Five Guys offers a diverse range of mix-ins that can be added to their milkshakes, allowing customers to personalize their dessert. These mix-ins can be categorized into several groups:
Chocolate-Based Mix-Ins
For chocolate lovers, Five Guys provides options like chocolate chips and chocolate syrup. These can be added to any milkshake flavor to intensify the chocolate experience.
Fruit Mix-Ins
Fruit mix-ins such as strawberries and blueberries are available for those looking to add a fruity twist to their milkshake. These can complement the base flavors or create a unique taste experience.
Candy and Cookie Mix-Ins
Candy pieces like M&M’s and cookie bits such as Oreos can be mixed into your milkshake, providing a fun textural element and a burst of flavor.
Nut-Based Mix-Ins
Nut-based mix-ins, including peanuts and peanut butter cups, offer a rich and nutty flavor that can be combined with various milkshake flavors.
Creating Your Perfect Custom Combination
With so many mix-ins available, the possibilities for creating a unique milkshake are endless. Here are some tips to help you craft your perfect combination:
How Many Mix-Ins Can You Add
Five Guys allows customers to add multiple mix-ins to their milkshakes. The number of mix-ins is largely up to personal preference, so feel free to experiment.
Best Flavor Pairings
Some popular flavor pairings include combining vanilla with chocolate chips and nuts, or strawberry with cookie bits. Don’t be afraid to try out different combinations to find your favorite.
Most Popular Custom Creations
While creativity is encouraged, some custom milkshake creations are more popular than others. Classics like the cookies and cream or the chocolate peanut butter cup are fan favorites among Five Guys enthusiasts.
Nutritional Information for Five Guys Milkshakes
The nutritional information of Five Guys milkshakes is essential for customers who want to enjoy their favorite hand-spun treats responsibly. As part of their commitment to transparency, Five Guys provides detailed nutritional data that helps customers make informed decisions.
Calorie Counts by Flavor and Size
Understanding the calorie count of your milkshake is the first step in making a healthier choice. The calorie content varies significantly based on the flavor and size of the milkshake.
Base Flavor Calories
Five Guys offers a variety of base flavors, each with its own calorie count. The Vanilla and Chocolate flavors are the most popular, with the regular size containing approximately 740 and 780 calories, respectively.
| Flavor | Regular Size Calories | Large Size Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Vanilla | 740 | 1160 |
| Chocolate | 780 | 1220 |
| Strawberry | 760 | 1190 |
How Mix-Ins Affect Calorie Count
Adding mix-ins can significantly increase the calorie count of your milkshake. For example, adding chocolate chips or peanut butter cups can add up to 100-150 calories per mix-in.
Sugar and Fat Content Breakdown
Besides calories, understanding the sugar and fat content is crucial for those monitoring their dietary intake. Five Guys milkshakes contain a considerable amount of sugar and fat, primarily due to their rich and creamy texture.
A regular-sized milkshake typically contains around 90-100 grams of sugar and 30-40 grams of fat, depending on the flavor and mix-ins.

Allergen and Dietary Information
For customers with dietary restrictions or allergies, it’s vital to know what’s in Five Guys milkshakes. The milkshakes contain dairy and are made in a environment where common allergens like nuts and gluten are present.
Common Allergens Present
Five Guys milkshakes are prepared in a kitchen that handles milk, eggs, nuts, and gluten. Customers with severe allergies should be aware of the risk of cross-contamination.
Considerations for Dietary Restrictions
For those with dietary restrictions, options are limited since the milkshakes are not vegan or gluten-free. However, customers can customize their milkshakes to some extent by choosing flavors and mix-ins that better fit their dietary needs.
The Best Five Guys Milkshake Flavor Combinations
Discover the ultimate Five Guys milkshake experience with our guide to the best flavor combinations. Five Guys is renowned for its hand-spun milkshakes, and mixing different flavors can create a truly unique treat. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or like to experiment, there’s a combination out there for everyone.
Top Customer-Favorite Combinations
Customers rave about certain Five Guys milkshake combinations that have become fan favorites. These popular mixes are a great starting point for anyone looking to try something new.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana
A decadent blend of rich chocolate, creamy peanut butter, and sweet banana, this combination is a match made in heaven. The peanut butter adds a nutty depth to the chocolate, while the banana provides a smooth finish.
Vanilla Oreo Milkshake
For those who love a cookies and cream flavor, the vanilla Oreo milkshake is a delicious twist on a classic. The crunch of the Oreos mixed with the creamy vanilla is irresistible.
Strawberry Banana Split
This fruity combination is perfect for warm weather. The sweetness of the strawberry and banana mix creates a refreshing milkshake that’s both healthy and indulgent.
Salted Caramel Chocolate
A sophisticated mix for those who enjoy a balance of sweet and salty, the salted caramel chocolate combination is a flavor sensation. The salted caramel adds a layer of complexity to the rich chocolate.
Employee-Recommended Mixes
Five Guys employees often have their own favorite milkshake combinations that they like to recommend to customers. These insider tips can help you discover new flavors.
- The “Cinnamon Sugar Rush” – a unique blend of cinnamon and sugar added to your milkshake for an extra kick.
- The “Nutty Delight” – combining peanut butter and chocolate for a creamy, nutty treat.
Secret Menu Combinations to Try
Some of the best Five Guys milkshake combinations aren’t on the menu but are worth trying. These secret mixes can elevate your milkshake experience.
- Try mixing strawberry and chocolate for a fruity twist on a classic flavor.
- Combine vanilla and peanut butter for a creamy, nutty treat.
How to Order Your Five Guys Milkshake
Now that you’ve explored the Five Guys Milkshake Menu and learned about the various flavors and customization options, it’s time to place your order. Ordering a Five Guys milkshake is a straightforward process that can be completed in-store or through their online ordering system.
To order, start by selecting your preferred milkshake flavor from the Five Guys Milkshake Menu. You can choose from a variety of base flavors and add mix-ins to create your perfect shake. If you’re unsure, consider trying one of the popular Five Guys shakes, such as the classic vanilla or chocolate.
Once you’ve decided on your milkshake, specify the size you prefer – either regular or large. If you’re feeling adventurous, don’t hesitate to ask for custom mix-ins or toppings to enhance your shake. The staff at Five Guys will be happy to guide you through the process and ensure your milkshake is made to your liking.